What to Ask Before You Sign With a Marketing Agency
If you own a trade shop in Indiana, you already know the pitch. A call or a message promising more leads, page-one rankings, and a phone that won't stop ringing. The deck looks sharp. The contract is long. Six months later, the report says you're doing great, and you're not sure what number those customers were calling.
I'm not against hiring help. I do this work for a living. I'm against signing before you know what you own, how success is measured, and how you get out if it isn't working.
These are the questions I'd want answered in writing. If a company gets fuzzy on them, that's your answer.
Who owns the domain, the site access, and the Google profile?
This is the first question, not the last. If you leave, do you keep the domain? Can you still log into your Google Business Profile? Who is listed as the owner, you or them?
A vendor can manage a Google Business Profile from a manager login. They do not need to take ownership, and they do not need to replace your number with theirs just to "get started." The same goes for the domain. It should be registered in your name, with a login you have.
Ask what happens to the website if you cancel. Some companies delete it. Some let you keep the words and photos, but not the site. Some will tell you that you own everything, then change the story later. Get the real version on paper. I explained how I handle this, including what does and doesn't transfer, in Own Your Domain and Google Profile Before You Sign.
If they can't answer this clearly, don't sign.
How will we know it's working?
Ask them to name the numbers they'll report, and how those numbers connect to your phone.
Impressions, clicks, and "brand visibility" are easy to make look good. They don't pay techs. You want calls, form fills, and, when you can get it, which of those turned into booked jobs. If they run ads, ask whether campaigns are tracked to calls and forms, or just to clicks.
Then ask to see a sample monthly report, with the vanity charts removed. If you can't read it, your office won't read it either. A straight report is short. Here's how you showed up. Here's how many people reached out. Here's what we changed. Here's what we recommend next.
Be wary of guaranteed rankings. Nobody can honestly promise that. Be wary of a company that wants a year of payments before they'll show you anything you can check for yourself.
What work, and which towns, are we actually targeting?
A national firm can spend a lot of money and still not know the difference between two towns twenty minutes apart. If you serve Plymouth, Bremen, and the lake towns, your pages and your ads should say so. If you don't want basement waterproofing jobs, your site shouldn't be built to attract them.
Ask:
- Which services are we trying to get more of?
- Which towns or counties will have pages?
- What work are we going to stop paying to attract?
If they talk about keywords and never talk about the jobs that make you money, they're optimizing for search terms, not for your business. A good contractor website is built around the work you want, in the places your trucks already go.
What's the contract, and how do I cancel?
Get the term in months, the price, what's included, and what happens if you want out. Read the cancellation section yourself. Don't rely on the salesperson's version of it.
Watch for automatic renewals, early cancellation fees, and "we'll just need to be a user on your Google listing" language that quietly hands them control. Watch for a company that keeps billing after you asked to cancel. That's not a misunderstanding. That's the business model.
Also ask who you'll talk to after the sale. If the person who promised the world disappears, and you're left with a ticket system, you already know how the next year will feel.
A fair agreement is easy to explain. You know the term, the cost, the work, and the way out.
Who answers when a homeowner calls?
If they put a tracking number on your site or your Google profile, ask what the caller hears. In a small town, a recording or a number that doesn't look like yours will cost you jobs. People hang up. They don't answer the callback.
Ask whether your real number stays visible, whether you control the tracking number, and whether you can take it off without losing the listing. I went deeper on that in How to Tell Where Your Contractor Calls Come From.
The whole point of marketing is a homeowner reaching you. If the system gets in the way of that, it isn't marketing.
A straight answer sounds like this
They can tell you what they own and what you own. They can tell you how they'll measure results, in numbers that match your phone. They can tell you which jobs and towns they're building for. They can show you the contract term and the cancellation process without a speech. They don't need to scare you into signing this week.
You should feel like you understand the deal, not like you need a translator.
If you want a plan and a number for your company, with those answers in plain English, tell me about the work. Your trade, your town, and what you want help with is enough. I'll reply myself.